Compare

AI interviewer vs interview copilot vs one-way video

Four ways to run a first-round interview, and what each one asks of your team and your candidates. The short version: an AI interviewer is the only one that holds a live, two-way interview without a person from your team in the call.

The four approaches side by side

Swipe the table sideways to see all four.

Live AI interviewerInterview copilotOne-way video interviewHuman phone screen
Who asks the questionsThe AI, live in the meetingA person; the AI listens and assistsQuestions shown on screen, recorded in advanceA person
Follow-up questionsYes, based on each answerOnly if the person asks themNo: the questions are fixedYes
Recruiter time per interviewNone during it; reading the report afterThe whole interviewWatching or reading every recordingThe whole call
Same questions and scoring for everyoneYes: one rubric, every answer scored with evidenceDepends on the interviewerSame questions; scoring depends on the reviewer or toolDepends on the interviewer
For the candidateA two-way conversation; they can ask to repeat or rephrase a questionA normal interviewTalking to a camera; nobody respondsA normal call
SchedulingAny time, including outside office hoursNeeds an interviewer's calendarThe candidate records any timeNeeds an interviewer's calendar
What you getA transcript and a scored reportNotes and a transcriptRecordings, sometimes with scoresThe interviewer's notes

Live AI interviewer

The AI joins the interview itself, asks the questions out loud, listens, follows up and grades every answer. With AI Hiring it joins your Microsoft Teams meeting, writes its questions from the candidate's resume and your job description, waits until the candidate has finished speaking, and gives you a report with a score for every answer and the candidate's own words as evidence. Your team reads the report and decides.

Interview copilot

A copilot or notetaker supports a person who runs the interview: it transcribes, summarises and may suggest questions. The interview is only as consistent as the person running it, and it still takes their time for every candidate.

One-way video interview

The candidate records answers to fixed questions on their own time. It saves scheduling, but there are no follow-ups, the candidate cannot ask what a question means, and someone still has to review the recordings.

Human phone screen

A recruiter or engineer calls the candidate. It is the most flexible option and the most expensive in team time, and two interviewers rarely ask the same questions or score the same way.

When an AI interviewer fits, and when it does not

  • Fits: first rounds where many candidates apply for the same role, technical screens, and hiring drives, for teams that already interview in Microsoft Teams. Every feature is free for 3 interviews a month; see pricing.
  • Does not fit: final rounds and senior hires, where a person from your team should meet the candidate; interviews in a language other than English, since AI Hiring interviews in English today; and meetings that admit only signed-in people, because the interviewer joins as a guest.

Try a live AI interviewer on your next first round

3 free interviews every month. No card needed.

Get started free